MORTGAGE AMOUNT $0
DOWN PAYMENT AMOUNT $185,185

MONTHLY MORTGAGE PAYMENT $0
ADDITIONAL MONTHLY CHARGES $0
TOTAL MONTHLY PAYMENT $0
CLOSE CALCULATOR
Days on Market: 0
Status: ACTIVE
MLS#: 408442
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 3
Living Area: 1550
Type: Condominium
Complex: Puamana
HOA Fees(monthly): $1266.45
Minatoya List: Yes
Offer Price: $1,234,567
Address: 5 Puakukui Pl Unit 5-2, Lahaina, HI 96761
Unit#: 5-2
MLS#: 408442
Posting Date: 01-17-2026 12:00am
Last Update: 01-16-2026 2:38pm

LISTING PROVIDED BY

Mark A. Marchello RB-17408
808-283-5296
MarkOnMaui@gmail.com

Mark A Marchello Inc
808-661-3484
MarkOnMaui@gmail.com

PROPERTY DESCRIPTION

Nestled just a 30-second walk from the beach, surf breaks and oceanfront pool, this rare opportunity in Puamana offers the chance to create a brand-new coastal retreat in one of West Maui’s most beloved oceanfront communities. The property previously hosted a legal 3-bedroom, 3-bath vacation-rental townhome, and approved plans have been submitted to rebuild the residence with the same 3BD/3BA configuration, preserving its legal short-term rental status with no additional rooms. The Association expects County permits shortly and plans to move forward with the construction of the new exterior shell, which is included in the purchase price. Once the shell is completed by the Association, the buyer will finish the interior from the studs in, allowing for full customization of finishes, layout details, and design—an increasingly rare opportunity in Puamana. A local Puamana contractor estimates interior build-out costs at approximately $250–$300 per square foot, plus furnishings. The approved floor plan is identical to Unit 111-2 (approx. 1,536 sq ft), a highly regarded layout featuring an open-concept living and dining area, a ground-floor bedroom and bath, and two upstairs en-suite bedrooms—designed for comfort, privacy, and effortless island living. The residence enjoys close proximity to the community pools, beach access, and the ocean lifestyle that defines Puamana. As the community thoughtfully rebuilds following the August 2023 fires, this offering represents a unique moment in time: the ability to secure a prime Puamana location, benefit from a brand-new exterior structure, and create a personalized interior vision—all within an established oceanfront resort community. An exceptional opportunity to invest in the next chapter of Puamana and build a future home that reflects the best of Maui living.

PRICE HISTORY

Date Days Ago Event Price

Last update: 2:38pm 1/16/2026

Disclaimer - This information is believed to be accurate. It has been provided by sources other than the Realtors Assoc. of Maui and should not be relied upon without independent verification. You should conduct your own investigation and consult with appropriate professionals to determine the accuracy of the information provided and to answer any questions concerning the property and structures located thereon. Featured properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting this brochure.